The All Progressives Congress (APC) is facing confusion over its Zamfara North senatorial rerun primary after two returning officers announced different winners of the exercise.
While one returning officer declared incumbent Senator Sahabi Ya’u Kaura the winner, another announced Senator Tijjani Yahaya Kaura as the party’s candidate for the 2027 general election.
The rerun primary took place on Monday, November 2, 2026, following a court order that nullified the party’s earlier exercise and directed it to conduct a fresh poll, Blueprint reports.
The Chairman of the APC Zamfara North Senatorial District Primary Election Committee, Dr Auwal Abdullahi Aliyu, declared Sahabi Ya’u the winner with 49,176 votes.
According to his announcement, Tijjani Yahaya Kaura scored 9,628 votes, while Sani Abdullahi Shinkafi received 2,602 votes.
Aliyu said the exercise complied with the law and the party’s electoral guidelines. He added that Sahabi Ya’u had met the requirements to emerge as the party’s candidate.
However, another returning officer, Sani Abdullahi, announced a different result, declaring Tijjani Yahaya Kaura the winner.
Under the second declaration, Tijjani secured 16,758 votes to defeat Sahabi Ya’u, who polled 1,465 votes. Shinkafi came third with 1,447 votes.
The rival announcements have raised questions about the credibility and final outcome of the exercise, leaving the APC’s candidate for the senatorial district uncertain.
Conflicting Results Raise Questions
The two declarations contain significant differences in the figures credited to the three aspirants.
The first returning officer gave Sahabi Ya’u 49,176 votes, while the second credited him with 1,465 votes.
Similarly, Tijjani received 9,628 votes in the first declaration and 16,758 in the second.
The figures for Shinkafi also differ. The first declaration’s headline figures reportedly credited him with 6,206 votes, although its detailed breakdown by local government areas totals 2,602.
The second declaration gave Shinkafi 1,447 votes.
These discrepancies have made it difficult to establish the official outcome pending clarification from the APC’s national leadership and relevant electoral authorities.
Court Ordered Fresh APC Primary
The rerun followed a legal dispute over the APC senatorial primary conducted on May 19, 2026, which initially produced Sahabi Ya’u as the party’s candidate for Zamfara North.
Shinkafi challenged the earlier exercise, alleging irregularities and non-compliance with the Electoral Act and the party’s electoral guidelines.
On August 31, the Federal High Court in Gusau ruled in his favour and ordered the APC to conduct a fresh primary.
Sahabi Ya’u challenged the judgment at the Court of Appeal sitting in Sokoto.
However, the appellate court dismissed his appeal on October 20 and upheld the order for a fresh exercise.
The ruling paved the way for Monday’s rerun involving the three aspirants.
Reported Violence Raises Concerns Over Primary
The rerun also reportedly experienced disruptions and violence at some voting centres, raising further concerns about the conduct of the exercise.
Reports indicated that electoral officials had yet to arrive at some polling locations by late morning, despite voters gathering to participate.
There were also reports of an attack on police personnel travelling along the Sokoto-Gusau road to provide security for the exercise.
However, the full circumstances of the reported attack and any casualty figures had not been independently established.
APC Yet To Resolve Zamfara North Candidate Dispute
The conflicting declarations have placed the APC leadership under pressure to clarify the authentic result and determine its candidate for the Zamfara North senatorial seat.
Until the party issues an authoritative position and resolves the discrepancies, neither aspirant can be regarded as the undisputed winner of the rerun primary.
