The Lagos State Special Offences Court sitting in Ikeja has admitted a certified true copy of a Supreme Court judgment upholding the forfeiture of seven properties, $2.045 million and share certificates linked to former Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Governor, Godwin Emefiele.
Justice Rahman Oshodi admitted the judgment as Exhibit L on Friday during Emefiele’s ongoing trial over alleged fraud involving $4.5 billion and ₦2.8 billion.
The development followed an application by the prosecution seeking to tender the judgment as part of its evidence in the criminal proceedings.
The prosecution, led by the Director of Public Prosecutions of the Federation, Rotimi Oyedepo, SAN, presented the document through an Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) investigator, Alvan Gurumnaan.
Overruling objections from the defence, Justice Oshodi held that a certified true copy of a Supreme Court judgment was admissible as a public document.
However, the judge restricted its evidential purpose, emphasising that it could only establish what the Supreme Court decided in the earlier forfeiture proceedings.
He clarified that the judgment could not be treated as evidence for or against any of the defendants in the ongoing criminal trial.
Defence Challenges Admission Of Judgment
Emefiele’s lawyer, Ojo Olalekan, SAN, opposed the admission of the document, arguing that the copy presented by the prosecution was signed by only four justices.
He contended that Supreme Court decisions are ordinarily delivered by panels comprising five or seven justices.
The defence counsel also argued that the judgment originated from non-conviction-based forfeiture proceedings and therefore had no direct relevance to the criminal charges currently facing Emefiele.
Counsel to the second defendant, Henry Omoile, Adeyinka Kotoye, SAN, supported the objection and urged the court to reject the document.
Responding, Oyedepo maintained that the judgment was a duly certified public document that satisfied Sections 102 and 104 of the Evidence Act.
He argued that the certification was sufficient to establish its admissibility and that the defence objections did not invalidate its status as a public record.
Supreme Court Restores Forfeiture Order
The Supreme Court judgment admitted by the trial court was delivered on July 17 by a five-member panel led by Justice Ibrahim Saulawa, who has since retired.
The apex court overturned an earlier decision of the Court of Appeal which had set aside a Federal High Court order granting the final forfeiture of the assets to the Federal Government.
It consequently restored the order issued by Justice D.I. Dipeolu of the Federal High Court on November 1, 2024, following an appeal by the EFCC.
The assets covered by the judgment include seven properties, $2.045 million and share certificates belonging to Queensdorf Global Fund Limited.
Among the properties are a duplex at 17B Hakeem Odumosu Street, Lekki Phase 1; an undeveloped parcel of land and a bungalow on Oyinkan Abayomi Drive, formerly Queens Drive, Ikoyi; and a four-bedroom duplex at 12A Probyn Road, Ikoyi.
Other assets include an industrial complex under construction on 22 plots of land in Agbor, Delta State; eight apartments at 8A Adekunle Lawal Road, Ikoyi; and a duplex at 2A Bank Road, Ikoyi.
The EFCC had argued that its investigation established reasonable grounds to suspect that the assets were acquired with proceeds of unlawful activities.
The commission pursued the forfeiture under Section 17 of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act, 2006.
EFCC Investigator Details Probe
Following the admission of the Supreme Court judgment, Gurumnaan continued giving evidence under cross-examination by the defence.
The EFCC investigator told the court that he personally obtained statements from witnesses, analysed bank records and coordinated other members of the investigation team.
He confirmed interviewing former Zenith Bank Managing Director, Ebenezer Onyeagwu, but said he could not immediately recall whether a formal statement was obtained from him after the interview.
Gurumnaan also disclosed that the investigation involved hundreds of interviews with officials of the CBN, commercial banks and personnel of other government agencies.
He said investigators examined financial transactions and other records to establish the alleged movement of funds and acquisition of properties linked to Emefiele and his associates.
Properties Allegedly Acquired Through Associates
At Thursday’s sitting, Gurumnaan told the court that investigators traced several properties worth billions of naira to Emefiele through some of his associates.
He alleged that certain individuals received money and subsequently acquired properties on behalf of the former CBN governor.
The properties mentioned included twin duplexes in Lekki Phase 1, two mansions on Queens Drive, Ikoyi, an 11-storey building under construction comprising about 94 luxury flats and an estate of approximately 750 houses in the Lokogoma district of Abuja.
The investigator further told the court that more than $2 million was recovered from the office of a lawyer, Ifeanyi Omeke.
According to Gurumnaan, Omeke allegedly admitted to acting as a front for Emefiele in some of the transactions under investigation.
The testimony forms part of the prosecution’s broader case involving alleged financial transactions and abuse of office.
Lokogoma Estate Linked To Separate Forfeiture Case
The Lokogoma estate mentioned during the proceedings was also the subject of a separate EFCC case involving Emefiele.
In that case, the former CBN governor was accused of acquiring 753 housing units alongside an alleged accomplice, Eric Ocheme.
The estate was subsequently forfeited to the Federal Government following proceedings initiated by the anti-graft agency.
The prosecution has continued to rely on evidence relating to properties and financial transactions as it seeks to establish its allegations against the former CBN governor.
Emefiele Faces 22-Count Charge
Emefiele is standing trial alongside his co-defendant, Henry Omoile, on a 22-count charge.
Nineteen counts relate directly to Emefiele and include allegations of receiving gratification, corrupt demands and abuse of office involving transactions valued at $4.5 billion and ₦2.8 billion.
The remaining three counts concern Omoile and allege unlawful acceptance of gifts.
Emefiele has denied the allegations and is contesting the charges before the court.
The trial is continuing, with the prosecution presenting witnesses and documentary evidence in support of its case.
